by Skullduggery » Mon Oct 14, 2002 1:47 pm
My personal feeling is that 'about' and 'help', as I've seen them used, are terribly redundant.
When I type 'about', for example, I expect to see something ABOUT the game itself, specifically...not how to play it. I expect to see things like a brief development history, how you got the idea, etc. I rarely see this in IF and it seems rather counterintuitive to use the 'about' function simply to describe generic IF commands.
Remember how Infocom's packaging used to include a brief walkthrough of some non-essential scene in the game to give the newbie player an idea of how to play? That's how I'd like to see 'help' implemented...perhaps as the opening sequence...'would you like HELP before you begin?' Not as these long tedious expositions on the history of IF, as well as an exhaustive list of every possible usable verb, unless of course you have some special word implemented that would not normally be tried.
Also, FWIW, I personally prefer all this info in the main text area, not off to the side or, god forbid, in popup window.
My personal feeling is that 'about' and 'help', as I've seen them used, are terribly redundant.
When I type 'about', for example, I expect to see something ABOUT the game itself, specifically...not how to play it. I expect to see things like a brief development history, how you got the idea, etc. I rarely see this in IF and it seems rather counterintuitive to use the 'about' function simply to describe generic IF commands.
Remember how Infocom's packaging used to include a brief walkthrough of some non-essential scene in the game to give the newbie player an idea of how to play? That's how I'd like to see 'help' implemented...perhaps as the opening sequence...'would you like HELP before you begin?' Not as these long tedious expositions on the history of IF, as well as an exhaustive list of every possible usable verb, unless of course you have some special word implemented that would not normally be tried.
Also, FWIW, I personally prefer all this info in the main text area, not off to the side or, god forbid, in popup window.