by Roody_Yogurt » Thu Apr 19, 2007 7:59 pm
I have played the remake, yes. A lot of what has been added is indeed sort of fun, although some of the art direction is kind of stupid, IMO (can't point out any particulars as it has been months since I have touched the game).
Overall, I think I had more fun with the original since victory seemed nearer, but both are just insanely past my capabilities. Still, just because I think it might be harder for you to jump into the original at this day and age (of course, my fond memories involve the C64; maybe the PC Pirates! Gold edition still holds up), I'd probably recommend playing the remake. You should have enough fun for a little while that you can at least imagine what was intriguing about it that we fans put long hours into it back in the day.
Aardvark also played both versions, didn't he? Maybe he has a different opinion.
I have played the remake, yes. A lot of what has been added is indeed sort of fun, although some of the art direction is kind of stupid, IMO (can't point out any particulars as it has been months since I have touched the game).
Overall, I think I had more fun with the original since victory seemed nearer, but both are just insanely past my capabilities. Still, just because I think it might be harder for you to jump into the original at this day and age (of course, my fond memories involve the C64; maybe the PC Pirates! Gold edition still holds up), I'd probably recommend playing the remake. You should have enough fun for a little while that you can at least imagine what was intriguing about it that we fans put long hours into it back in the day.
Aardvark also played both versions, didn't he? Maybe he has a different opinion.